The Wonder of Wine

There are two schools of school in the world and while I have come to believe my spirit belongs to one I have enthusiastically spent most of my life in the other.

From primary school to post-graduate education, from short courses to long ones, the same process has been applied to my acquisition of knowledge: a well-worn process of studying, cramming and passing. Rinse and repeat. These have genuinely been some of the happiest and most rewarding times of my life, yet also the most trying and most boring. And I’m not done yet.

Curiously, some sections of the business world ask little of us intellectually. The bigger the business, the more it requires us to surrender independent thought to processes more proven, models well-tested and actions risk averse. Creative thinking is reserved for ‘away days’ and a whiteboard. Imagination distilled to something that can be expressed in a spreadsheet.

While learning and applying and learning and applying, something counterproductive happens. We stop wondering. Which is a shame as I have come to learn, there is a lot to be found in wonder.

I didn’t work this out until I left it all and had time to wonder when I realised that some of the richest insights come when we have space and time to reflect. And I got to thinking that with wine there is a lot to be discovered outside the classroom, especially when it comes to learning about place.

Who better to offer lessons about place than the grand masters themselves: the modern naturalists. American writer Barry Lopez wrote in his essay The Naturalist that “almost every day I go down to the river with no intention but to sit and watch.” He has done this for thirty years and encourages us to “pay attention to the mystery”. Charles Darwin observed what became known as the theory of natural selection many years before he wrote about it; wondering and observing for three decades in between. And everyone’s favourite outdoorsman, Henry David Thoreau, famously checked out for two years where he “went to the woods because he wished to live deliberately” before writing the spirited person’s guidebook, Walden. Consciously or not, they all gave themselves time and space to observe the world, rather than rushing to collect information to then be recited back in the appropriate order as proof of knowledge.

To be honest, I don’t feel all that knowledgeable when I can list things about Burgundy because I’ve read them in a book and tasted the wines. Sure, I know more than when I didn’t know the facts, and I know what to look for when I get there, and these pieces will one day join together to form knowledge, but it feels a bit superficial. I feel as if I’m cheating; like saying I’ve experienced Italy because I’ve read the guidebook and eaten at Grossi Florentino.

I’m not arguing against a particular style of education (how can I? I went to business school) and I am certainly not against education itself. As I said, I’m not even done with it yet. It’s just that I know now that having all the information in the world is not always the answer. There is a whole school out there with no prerequisite but an open mind and a willingness to wonder.

For now, I am not so interested in rote-learning information that I’m likely to forget with the effects of my first celebratory drink. I’m interested in the other kind. I want to wallow in the wonder of wine. I want to get a sense of place by sensing the place – tasting, seeing, smelling and watching, going beyond information and letting it become, as Lopez says, “what the body knows”.

With this in mind, I’ve booked a ticket to the Old World. It seems as good a place as any, where I am going to the vineyards because I wish to learn deliberately.

This entry was posted in People, Wine and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to The Wonder of Wine

  1. Dan Sims says:

    Another great post Frosty and so very, very true. I see so many young, enthusiastic Sommeliers forcing themselves to learn facts, figures, clonal selections or the sub-regions of some obscure wine producing country that they’ve just heard of though have never, nor more than likely ever, taste wine from.

    As you say, learning to list & repeat information makes you do exactly that, list and repeat. How that knowledge is translated and communicated and delivered is whats important.

    As another wise person once said ‘there is a big difference between knowledge and wisdom.’

    (I actually think that was Yoda). ;)

    Loving your work Frosty!

    Cheers

  2. Dearest Andrea,

    Coincidentally I was having a similar debate with a colleague this morning about different ways of learning, absorbing and applying that knowledge. We too were talking in reference to wine. The discussion evolved because we noted that there are a number of structured courses out there that are building a more common ground for people in the wine trade to work around.

    I understand the importance of these courses, but I also look at them warily because of how different it lies in relation to how my own learning was developed.

    The point is Andrea, that you have just made the best possible investment in your own education. The people you will meet, the stories they will tell, the food and wine you will share, all placed in the context of where you will travel will help to weave a thread of knowledge that is inimitable and the stories all yours.

    I look forward to hearing about all the finer details.

    Krystina

  3. Louise Hemsley-Smith says:

    Nice one Frosty, really enjoying your posts. Cheers LHS

  4. Erez says:

    I love books and reading. I love them deeply. But no book has ever left me with juice-stained hands, muddy boots and the taste of sunshine on my tongue. They have only alerted me to the possibilities.

    Great work Frosty.

  5. Stu says:

    Brilliant!

    And it all starts at such a young age when we seem intent on removing the wonder of everything from little people, to shunt them into a system of servile norms, and teaching the ability to pass exams.

    Great piece and I look forward to hearing of your journeys in the old world.

  6. Soph says:

    As always, superbly written.

    Can I come too? I will sit and watch….

  7. Di says:

    Miss Andrea, a very nice piece of writing (as usual). Wonder, wander and write! I look forward to reading.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>